Should we be concerned about lead in drinking water?

leadWould you believe that the Roman Empire crumbled due to a lack of sugar and that an extreme fondness for sauerkraut brought the British Empire to its knees?  I’m not sure I believe it, but there is a fascinating, although contentious, theory that implies this is just what happened.  The Romans had a sweet tooth, but didn’t know about sugar.  So they boiled down grape juice to make a sweet syrup called “sapa” which they added to wine, as well as to various foods.  The acidic juices were boiled in lead vessels because experience had shown that this enhanced the sweetness of the product.  Of course the chemical nuances of the procedure were unknown to the Romans, but we now understand that acids can readily leach lead from containers.  Indeed, lead acetate is sometimes referred to as “sugar of lead.”

One of the amazing features of lead is its extreme toxicity.  Regular intake in the milligram range can have catastrophic consequences.  Stomach cramps, weakness, headaches, irritability, loss of appetite, anemia, high blood pressure and kidney problems are classic symptoms of lead poisoning.  These are nasty enough, but perhaps the most insidious aspect of lead is that it can be devastating over the long term at intakes which are too low to cause overt symptoms.  Mental confusion and impairment of judgement have been connected with chronic low level exposure.  The Roman ruling classes would have been the most affected because they drank more sweetened wine, usually from lead-based pewter mugs and had access to water that was delivered through lead pipes.  Caligula’s orgies, poor military decisions by Roman Emperors and Nero’s fiddling while Rome burned, essentially the components of the fall of the Empire, have been linked with exposure to lead.  While this may sound somewhat fanciful, there is actually archeological evidence to bolster the lead poisoning theory.

The toxicity of lead is partly due to its chemical resemblance to calcium.  Calcium is essential for a myriad biochemical reactions and of course is one of the main building blocks of bone.  When lead is present in the system, our bodies can mistake it for calcium and incorporate it into bone where it can be readily detected by x-rays.  Remember how Superman’s x-ray vision was always stymied by lead shields?  Archeologists have x-rayed some ancient Roman skeletons and have indeed found abnormal levels of lead.  And abnormal levels of lead may also have set the sun on the British Empire.  George III was king of Britain during the American Revolution and some historians have suggested that it was his inept handling of the situation that led to the loss of the Colonies.  George was not only inept, he was close to being insane.  His madness has been widely attributed to porphyria, a disease of faulty hemoglobin production.  It is usually an inherited condition, often characterized by purple urine, which George was known to produce.  But lead poisoning can also cause similar symptoms.  And how was George exposed to lead?  Being of German ancestry, he loved sauerkraut.  His cooks prepared it in lead pots, almost exclusively for the King.  Sauerkraut was not a delicacy favored by the royal subjects, so conceivably, only George suffered the serious effects of lead poisoning.

Whether or not lead played a part in the downfall of the Roman and British Empires may be just an academic question.  But whether or not our own lives are being attacked by this stealthy intruder is a question of great practical importance.  Peeling paint and crumbling walls may not sound like weapons of war, but they can mount a pretty effective assault on health.  Lead carbonate was the main white pigment used in paint up to about 1950 and was still in common use until 1980 when it was eventually phased out.  Scientists had become concerned because lead from paint was finding its way into people’s bodies, particularly young children in poor neighborhoods who had a fondness for putting flakes of peeling paint into their mouths.  As it turns out, one milligram of lead from paint, ingested daily, can cause poisoning.  A window sill often accumulates paint dust just from the normal up and down movement of the window frame.  Touching this and then sucking on a thumb can lead to the ingestion of dangerous amounts of lead.  And here is the really scary finding.  The poisoning may not be immediately apparent.  Indeed, it may show up only years later as aggressive behavior, learning disabilities, poor speech articulation, hyperactivity or a subtle drop in IQ!

Millions of children in North America have high blood levels of lead and they do not necessarily live in old dilapidated buildings.  Some parents have inadvertently made their children sick by carrying out home renovations which generated lead-laden dust.  Although drugs are available to rid the blood of lead, that which has deposited in the brain remains forever, permanently impairing mental performance.  And it is not only children who can be affected.  One of my colleagues, ironically an analytical chemist, experienced this tragic scenario firsthand.  Dust from renovations in his stately old residential building drifted into his apartment.  At first this was just an annoying cleaning problem but soon his wife and mother-in-law began to experience symptoms which were consistent with lead toxicity.  The lead-filled dust became a life-changing nightmare.

We have to take lead pollution seriously.  Renovations in houses which may have lead paint must be carried out by contractors who have proper training and equipment.  A screening program for lead in the blood of children in underprivileged areas may be the best way to find problem homes.  Massive federal funding will be needed to remove the paint and in some cases even the soil around the house which may harbor paint chips.  Children’s nutritional status will also have to be evaluated.  Adequate calcium and vitamin C intake can significantly reduce lead absorption, but it is precisely these nutrients that poor children lack.  Drinking water should also be monitored and a filter used if lead levels are above 10 parts per billion.  Nero watched as Rome burned, possibly as a result of lead poisoning.  Modern chemistry has given us ways to monitor lead in our environment and techniques to deal with the problem appropriately.  Sweeping the paint dust under the carpet is tantamount to fiddling with the problem while lives and children’s potential burn.

Joe Schwarcz

One Response to “Should we be concerned about lead in drinking water?”

  1. Sandra Libby says:

    My house is 120 years old and I still have a lead inlet from the street. The city of St. Lambert admits there are still older homes here with the same pipes. My plumber tells me that there are homes in Westmount that still have lead inlets. My house has been in the family for the 120 years and my 3 sisters and I all grew up here with no problems. So lead paint is a problem but what about lead water inlets to a house?
    PS I have the Snopes website bookmarked on my computer and now I have the OSS website bookmarked. Both have the same agenda. Very good!

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Blog authors are solely responsible for the content of the blogs listed in the directory. Neither the content of these blogs, nor the links to other web sites, are screened, approved, reviewed or endorsed by McGill University. The text and other material on these blogs are the opinion of the specific author and are not statements of advice, opinion, or information of McGill.