Don’t Blame the Water Bottle!

bottled waterI’ve repeatedly been asked about the circulating email that claims Sheryl Crow blames her breast cancer on chemicals leaching out of water bottles and warns women to never keep bottled water in the car in summer. Well, first of all, Sheryl didn’t actually say that her breast cancer was caused by having left water bottles in a car. And what if she had? Is Sheryl an icon of science? Hardly. Unfortunately the singer was diagnosed with breast cancer and when such a calamity occurs people commonly look for possible causes of their affliction. The lay press is filled with articles demonizing plastics, mostly in an unjustified fashion and Sheryl likely heard about chemicals like bisphenol A and the phthalates that have been accused of causing cancer. Neither of these are present in the kind of water bottles Sheryl was concerned about. Bisphenol A is used to make polycarbonate plastics which are used in the large carboys that sit on top of water coolers but not in the commonly used water bottles. These are made of polyester. And here some confusion about phthalates enters the picture. One of the chemicals used to make polyester is terepthalic acid. There could conceivably be trace amounts of this that leach into the water. The “hot car” connection comes from the correct notion that an increase in temperature increases the leaching of water-soluble compounds from plastic. But terepthalic acid is not the phthalate that has been implicated by some in health problems. That is diethylhexylphthalate, a chemical added to some plastics, mostly to polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The only PVC used in water bottles is in the cap, any leaching from that would be trivial. And it needs to be emphasized that there is no credible evidence that bisphenol A or phthalates play a role in breast cancer. Sadly Sheryl Crow now has been diagnosed with a brain tumour. She wonders whether this was caused by her use of a cell phone. Not according to the vast majority of studies. Cancer is a terrible disease and in most cases the cause is unknown, which of course opens the door to all sorts of speculation. I think bottled water should be shunned. But not because of any cancer connection. It is an environmental disaster. Only a small percentage of the bottles are recycled and using valuable petroleum resources to make bottles that are totally unnecessary is foolish. But the bottled water industry has done a wonderful job convincing the public that they need to pay for something that is widely available for free.

Joe Schwarcz

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Blog authors are solely responsible for the content of the blogs listed in the directory. Neither the content of these blogs, nor the links to other web sites, are screened, approved, reviewed or endorsed by McGill University. The text and other material on these blogs are the opinion of the specific author and are not statements of advice, opinion, or information of McGill.