Forget licorice for prostate problems!

licoriceA 67-year-old Chinese man sought medical help in a Taipei hospital because of progressive muscular weakness. Aside from somewhat elevated blood pressure he had been in good health. Doctors could find no abnormality except for a very low level of potassium in the blood. The man revealed that he had been taking a Chinese herbal remedy for his enlarged prostate. It turned out the remedy contained licorice root. Licorice has a long history in Chinese herbal medicine as a general healing agent. While the accounts of miraculous cures are highly suspect, glycyrrhizic acid, the active principle in the licorice root certainly does have physiological effects. Licorice was one of the first drugs used in the treatment of Addison’s disease by western physicians. This is an ailment of the adrenal glands which results in reduced production of cortisol, a hormone that helps regulate blood pressure and water retention. It turns out that glycyrrhizic acid interferes with an enzyme that normally breaks down excess cortisol in the kidney. If you are really interested, the enzyme in question is 11-betahydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 2! In any case, inactivation of this enzyme leads to elevated cortisol levels which can cause hypertension. Furthermore, high cortisol causes retention of sodium and excretion of potassium. Sodium retention in turn leads to excess water retention in the body. Potassium deficiency causes muscle weakness. The remedy? Remove the licorice and treat the patient with potassium supplements. In two weeks the gentleman had lost 2 kg in weight due to the elimination of water retention and his potassium and blood pressure returned to normal. All signs of muscle weakness disappeared. Physicians and patients need to be aware of the fact that licorice root may be lurking in herbal therapies and can lead to problems. Incidentally, there is no evidence that licorice has any benefit in the treatment of benign prostate hypertrophy.

Joe Schwarcz

2 Responses to “Forget licorice for prostate problems!”

  1. Joe Schwarcz says:

    Oh really? “For thousands of years in China they have been healing people with natural herbs and remedies” I would like to see some evidence for that other than anecdotes. Reliance on “ancient wisdom” is not wise. Bloodletting went on for thousands of years..and turned out to be not so wise. Nobody is dismissing herbal remedies; many of the commonly used pharmaceuticals derive from plants. But these have been properly tested and dosages determined through clinical trials. That cannot be said for the herbal preparations available in health food stores. Their composition is essentially unknown and quality control and “evidence” are left up to the marketers. It is up to those making a claim to provide the proper evidence. For most herbal products that are commercially marketed the evidence is scant.

  2. Of course, any qualified naturopath or health care practitioner would know that licorice root should never be taken long term. Should not be taken by those with hypertension, diabetes, kidney disfunction, cardiac problems, edema. Should be accompanied by foods that are high in potassium. Unfortunately there will always be some in every profession who are unqualified, but there is no reason to shed a negative light on all herbal therapies. For thousands of years in China they have been healing people with natural herbs and remedies and documenting and categorizing the results. This seems a lot more significant than a 6 week double blind study done with a placebo and funded by a pharmaceutical company proving that their drug is going to work.

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Blog authors are solely responsible for the content of the blogs listed in the directory. Neither the content of these blogs, nor the links to other web sites, are screened, approved, reviewed or endorsed by McGill University. The text and other material on these blogs are the opinion of the specific author and are not statements of advice, opinion, or information of McGill.